I read a great post today thanks to Larissa Reynolds, a good friend down in the great state of Texas. The post was written on http://cuhype.com and entitled "Hello, Our members are Morons". The author identified only as "Tony" was discussing how when he would pitch a Credit Union (his marketing specialty area) on a new marketing idea they'd frequently shoot it down saying that their members "wouldn't get it". He went on to explain why this was really a fallacy, and that with the right message and the right delivery you can hook a lot of people you wouldn't just assume would get it. Management's assumption seemed to be that it was ok for THEM but that their MEMBERS wouldn't get it, understand it, or be able to do it. This sort of belies the fact that most of THEM are members of their own credit union :)
I was reminded of a particular phrase that I usually use with my entrepreneurs when they come to me with their ideas. Take Knowledge Athletes for instance. They come to me with a great educational idea and I have said more times than once "you guys are the education experts - I'm just the software developer". If they think it's a great idea - it's worth a try.
Which is not to say I don't push back sometimes for a simpler interface. It's my job to advise people on the best way to implement their idea so that it can be enjoyed by the widest audience. But we must always be careful not to dumb something down to the point of no returns. It's ok for our users to have a brain - and to need it to accomplish a task.
We were pleasantly suprised for instance how quickly kids were able to pick up the Kajour application and run with it - sometimes despite bugs and growing pains caused by it only being a demo system. We found we could make the interface much more complicated than we originally anticipated and it would still work great for the kids. They were USED to figuring out complex interfaces. They'd grown up in the world of Facebook, MySpace, YouTube, and other tools and didn't mind poking around in menus or selecting icons until they could figure out what they needed.
So the all around summary - don't assume your users can't use a sophisticated interface. Don't underestimate their ability to "get it".
Want to build a business? You need an IT ecosystem.
50 minutes ago



4 comments:
Hi Lee, great follow-up! I'm with you on always refining to interface to be simpler, but that's simple as in elegant and uncomplicated, not simple-minded. ;)
Thanks for a great post!
@lareynolds
Interesting article Lee, for a couple of reasons. When I read your opening paragraph, I thought you were headed in the direction of "Seymours", as in Selling to Vito, but as I read on, I realized you were commenting on the sophistication of the user population of a product. So, ... THANKS for writing this. The students who are using kajour are indeed sophisticated online users of social networking products and have nearly a whole year under their belts of loving the experience - they have even said so in numerous survey questions and the occasional, in-the-hallway conversation about the site. The balancing act that I know we're discovering, and implementing, is to make it easy enough to use, but with the sophistication of the end-user in mind. It's great working with today's students - they really get the online experience - and I call it that because to them, it's not technology. Thanks for sharing your experience with Knowledge Athletes, Lee - Dave
Lee,
Thanks for the nod in our direction. My post came from a point of frustration that everyone seems to think they are a genius but everyone else is a moron.
I have also made the point about web based interfaces being overly simplified because the folks in charge think that their members are so old that they will not be able to use the site. I have to quickly rebut with "The fastest growing sector of MySpace users are in the over-50 category." to show that if your menu is at least as simple at a MySpace page - you are probably ok.
If your memebrs are still unable to use the site, they are probably not using online banking anyway. That means you are spending a lot of time making a ham sandwich for a vegetarian. They just have no need for it.
Also a thanks to Larissa for sharing my thoughts with you ;)
Tony Mannor
Andermahr & Company
CuHype.com
Tony,
I know this is a late reply, but just FYI - my 97 year old Grandma just signed up for a facebook account. You're NEVER too old :)
Cheers,
Lee
Post a Comment